educational

Getting Paid? Part 1

There’s an ongoing battle between surfers, adult Webmasters, the companies who provide credit card processing services, and the credit card companies themselves. The issues are complex, the stakes are high – and the outcome will affect everyone in this industry. The latest battle features Epoch and MasterCard, and the war is underway:

MasterCard (along with VISA) enjoys a virtual monopoly over the issuance of credit cards – a monopoly so severe that it effectively prevents any serious competition from entering the current market. Being ‘the only game in town’ allows MasterCard to alter their terms and fees without fear of losing a substantial portion of its customer base, and it is this practical reality that allows them to do as they wish, regardless of the impact that their actions have on merchants and IPSPs (Internet Payment Service Providers) – a situation that at least one IPSP is attempting to redress through litigation.

On May 12th, 2003, Paycom / Epoch filed suit against MasterCard over a wide-ranging variety of issues, some of which will be discussed in this article. Adult Webmasters in particular should be following these events closely, for in my opinion, the vagaries of payment processing and the long-term viability of being able to accept credit cards for recurring adult site membership fees is now the single greatest threat to our industry – and a threat that cannot be so easily overcome.

These issues transcend the current dispute between Epoch and MasterCard, and whether directly (as in the case of IPSPs and their clients), or indirectly (as in the case of ‘free site’ and other Webmasters who send traffic to affiliate programs, and the Web hosts, designers, coders and other Net ‘infrastructure’ providers who rely upon income generated from the clients of IPSPs), affect nearly everyone in our industry.

Issue 1: Merchants Bear the Risk of Fraud
Credit Card fraud is a serious and growing concern for all merchants, but for many e-commerce merchants (whether their products are ‘adult’ in nature or not) it may very well be a ‘life or death’ issue. I suspect one reason online fraud is higher than in more traditional settings is the relative ‘anonymity’ customers perceive. This allows them to feel more secure about using stolen credit cards online where their threat of capture is almost nil – or (more commonly in the adult industry) of later denying a legitimate purchase authorization (so-called “friendly fraud”) when the consequences of their membership to an adult Web site become all too clear (which is usually on the same day that the wife opens their latest MasterCard bill).

While there is no practical way to stop a lying spouse, pre-approval ‘scrubbing’ of transactions against a ‘negative database’ of known fraudulent users can mitigate some of the losses from what$is essentially a willful (and criminal) “theft of service.” This common approach, along with address verification protocols and other proprietary techniques that are employed by IPSPs all help to reduce the occurrences of fraud, however, one other major issue of fraud remains: MasterCard will not provide a timely list of known stolen credit card numbers to IPSPs for inclusion in their negative databases!

While it might be easy to say “if MasterCard doesn’t want to share what it knows about which cards are stolen, then that’s their problem!” the real problem is that they actually penalize the IPSP for processing a transaction on one of these accounts – something which could easily be avoided by them simply saying “Hey, don’t run that card – it’s been reported stolen!”

These penalties are not insignificant, either: In addition to having to develop in-house fraud reduction measures, as well as shoulder the cost of a customer service staff, and the infrastructure necessary to support it, IPSPs (and indeed, most other merchants with in-house customer service staff) must refund all charges to customers who call and then complain about their charges, asserting that they never authorized the same. This so-called “friendly fraud” is the credit card industry’s “dirty little secret.” Beyond this expense, IPSPs must refund the costs of chargebacks to the Issuing Banks, pay MasterCard the ‘Discount Rate’ of the transaction (their fee for accepting the purchase charge, just as if the declined charge had been successfully transacted), and on top of all this pay per-chargeback fees and other penalties!

With no practical method for merchants to dispute the voracity of a consumer-induced “friendly fraud” and the credit card companies and merchant banks refusal to implement technological solutions to this problem, and even worse, advertising the fact that consumers are not liable for “mystery charges” appearing on their statements (encouraging their deceitful theft of service), it is no wonder that so many in our industry are feeling an untenable – and seemingly irresolvable – negative economic impact.

The issue of online credit card fraud will continue to plague both merchants and processors until a secure means of positively verifying a cardholder’s purchase authorization can be developed and implemented. Stay tuned for the next installment in this series, where we’ll look at more of the factors that could lead to the end of our industry as we know it. ~ Stephen

Copyright © 2025 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More Articles

opinion

WIA Profile: Lainie Speiser

With her fiery red hair and a laugh that practically hugs you, Lainie Speiser is impossible to miss. Having repped some of adult’s biggest stars during her 30-plus years in the business, the veteran publicist is also a treasure trove of tales dating back to the days when print was king and social media not even a glimmer in the industry’s eye.

Women in Adult ·
opinion

Fighting Back Against AI-Fueled Fake Takedown Notices

The digital landscape is increasingly being shaped by artificial intelligence, and while AI offers immense potential, it’s also being weaponized. One disturbing trend that directly impacts adult businesses is AI-powered “DMCA takedown services” generating a flood of fraudulent Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA) notices.

Corey D. Silverstein ·
opinion

Building Seamless Checkout Flows for High-Risk Merchants

For high-risk merchants such as adult businesses, crypto payments are no longer just a backup plan — they’re fast becoming a first choice. More and more businesses are embracing Bitcoin and other digital currencies for consumer transactions.

Jonathan Corona ·
opinion

What the New SCOTUS Ruling Means for AV Laws and Free Speech

On June 27, 2025, the United States Supreme Court handed down its landmark decision in Free Speech Coalition v. Paxton, upholding Texas’ age verification law in the face of a constitutional challenge and setting a new precedent that bolsters similar laws around the country.

Lawrence G. Walters ·
opinion

What You Need to Know Before Relocating Your Adult Business Abroad

Over the last several months, a noticeable trend has emerged: several of our U.S.-based merchants have decided to “pick up shop” and relocate to European countries. On the surface, this sounds idyllic. I imagine some of my favorite clients sipping coffee or wine at sidewalk cafés, embracing a slower pace of life.

Cathy Beardsley ·
profile

WIA Profile: Salima

When Salima first entered the adult space in her mid-20s, becoming a power player wasn’t even on her radar. She was simply looking to learn. Over the years, however, her instinct for strategy, trust in her teams and commitment to creator-first innovation led her from the trade show floor to the executive suite.

Women in Adult ·
opinion

How the Interstate Obscenity Definition Act Could Impact Adult Businesses

Congress is considering a bill that would change the well-settled definition of obscenity and create extensive new risks for the adult industry. The Interstate Obscenity Definition Act, introduced by Sen. Mike Lee, makes a mockery of the First Amendment and should be roundly rejected.

Lawrence G. Walters ·
opinion

What US Sites Need to Know About UK's Online Safety Act

In a high-risk space like the adult industry, overlooking or ignoring ever-changing rules and regulations can cost you dearly. In the United Kingdom, significant change has now arrived in the form of the Online Safety Act — and failure to comply with its requirements could cost merchants millions of dollars in fines.

Cathy Beardsley ·
opinion

Understanding the MATCH List and How to Avoid Getting Blacklisted

Business is booming, sales are steady and your customer base is growing. Everything seems to be running smoothly — until suddenly, Stripe pulls the plug. With one cold, automated email, your payment processing is shut down. No warning, no explanation.

Jonathan Corona ·
profile

WIA Profile: Leah Koons

If you’ve been to an industry event lately, odds are you’ve heard Leah Koons even before you’ve seen her. As Fansly’s director of marketing, Koons helps steer one of the fastest-growing creator platforms on the web.

Women in Adult ·
Show More